Head to head · Multi-agent orchestration · October 2026 research run

Crush vs herdr

herdr scores 71.1 (BB) on agent readiness against Crush's 53.3 (D), and leads in 6 of 7 scored categories. Crush leads on maintenance & community. Both do multi-agent orchestration.

Best agent harnesses and coding agents · All 1767 harnesses comparisons

Which one, for what

Crush D

Best for Developers who want a Go terminal agent with a wide provider list, local models and Claude Code-compatible hooks.

Ahead on

  • Maintenance & community, 82 against 63

Also in its favour

  • Free to start without a card

Watch for

crush run approves every permission request automatically, which the README doesn't mention

herdr BB

Best for A developer who runs several coding agents in terminals, locally or over SSH, and wants one agent to start, prompt and wait on others.

Ahead on

  • Reliability, 65 against 52
  • Schema & documentation, 91 against 65
  • Agent ergonomics, 73 against 52
  • Security & auth, 49 against 41
  • Payments & pricing, 90 against 83
  • Transparency & trust, 70 against 59

Also in its favour

  • Agent-ready, a grade of BB or better
  • No key needed to call it
  • Open source
  • No incidents deducted, where Crush loses 6 points for them

Watch for

Version 0.9.5, not yet 1.0, and the last tagged release is 14 October 2026

Why the edge

Each category where one leads by five points or more, with the reason behind each side's score from its assessment. The numbers are in the table below; this is what they stand for.

Schema & documentation herdr +26

Crush 65

Harness reading of the framework line. A JSON Schema for the config at https://charm.land/crush.json (also printed by crush schema), --json on the session commands, and an OpenAPI document that crush server generates from its endpoint list and serves at /v1/docs/openapi.json, which isn't published anywhere we could fetch. crush run output has no typed form (20). No llms.txt (charm.land/llms.txt is a not-found page). The docs are Markdown in the repository and the hooks guide says it was written for humans and agents (5). The README and config docs explain when to allow, deny or hook a tool and warn that configs run as code (12). The schema carries enums and defaults, such as the attribution trailer style, while permissions take bare tool names with no command patterns (11). Many examples for providers, MCP, hooks and local models, with no reference for error messages or exit codes (9). Version tags and GitHub releases with generated notes, which we couldn't open, and no changelog file (8).

herdr 91

Read as a CLI and socket API. herdr api schema --json prints a JSON Schema for requests, responses, errors and events, also at docs/next/api/herdr-api.schema.json (25). Markdown for agents, with skills/herdr/SKILL.md and distribution/agent-guide.md. https://herdr.dev/llms.txt indexes the 0.9.5 docs as raw source files for agents (10). The skill says when to use herdr and when not to, and the socket docs say which layer to use for which job, but the schema itself carries few descriptions (15). The schema has 49 enums and agent names are constrained by a pattern, while some inputs are free strings (12). Many CLI and JSON examples, a documented error shape with codes such as not_found, agent_blocked and events_lost (14). Versioned docs per release and a changelog (15). 25 + 10 + 15 + 12 + 14 + 15 = 91.

Agent ergonomics herdr +21

Crush 52

Harness reading, scored on what an agent or pipeline driving crush run has to supply. About 20 built-in tools, any of which permissions deny hides, MCP servers take per-server disabled_tools, and skills can be turned off or kept out of the model's list. No lazy loading of MCP tools found (17). No turn, time or cost limit on crush run, and the only output controls are --quiet and --verbose (6). Errors come back as plain messages with a non-zero exit, such as the one for an unconfigured provider, with no documented codes and no JSON error record (8). --session and --continue resume a run, and crush session list, show, last, rename and delete take --json (13). One argument starts a run and environment keys are picked up, but there's no SDK, and the HTTP API needs CRUSH_CLIENT_SERVER=1 and is described only in one README section (8).

herdr 73

Framework reading, how much an agent has to carry. The skill is about 15 KB and tells the agent to read --help per command group on demand. Reads take --lines and --source recent (20 of 25). Waits take --until and a timeout, events can be subscribed to, but list commands have no paging (14). Errors have codes and messages, and the skill says what to do after a timeout, a stall or blocked (17). agent prompt --wait submits and waits in one request to avoid a race, agent.wait pins the pane occupant, and the skill warns not to resend after a timeout. No idempotency keys (14). Most commands default to the caller's or focused pane. No SDK, only the CLI and raw socket (8). 20 + 14 + 17 + 14 + 8 = 73.

Maintenance & community Crush +19

Crush 82

v0.99.0 tagged on 29 October 2026 (6 days, 30). 21 release tags from 7 August to 29 October, v0.88.1 to v0.99.0, besides a moving nightly tag that isn't counted (20). The 18 October shields.io counts are struck. The repository's refs show 147 merges into main and 438 commits in the 90 days to 4 November, with 272 open pull requests carrying a merge ref, and new contributors signing the CLA most days. Reply times couldn't be read (12). No SDK, as with other harnesses. npm, Homebrew, Winget, Scoop, apt, yum and NUR builds come from the release workflow (12, held partial). Dependabot, a go mod tidy check in CI and nightly security scans, with CI results unread (8). 30 + 20 + 12 + 12 + 8 = 82.

herdr 63

v0.9.5 on 14 October 2026, 35 days before the check, and the last commit on master on 29 October (20). Six releases from 7 September to 14 October 2026 (20). 495 open issues and 26 open pull requests. The 25 newest issues were labelled triaged with a priority within a day of opening. Unsolicited pull requests are closed automatically and a monthly workflow closes stale issues (15). Not an MCP server and no official SDK (0). Cargo.lock, Dependabot and CI on three systems, run results unread (8). 20 + 20 + 15 + 0 + 8 = 63.

Reliability herdr +13

Crush 52

Local-package reading. @charmland/crush on npm, a Homebrew tap, Winget, Scoop, AUR, Nix, FreeBSD pkg, Charm's apt and yum repositories and release binaries, with supported platforms named in the README (20). The public build workflow runs go test -race -failfast ./... on Linux, macOS and Windows for every push to main and every pull request, but GitHub pages and the API answer 403 to us, so results are unread (15). The 18 October issue and pull request counts came from shields.io badges, a third-party copy of GitHub data, and are struck. The repository's own refs show 2,574 pull requests to #4224, 272 of them open with a merge ref, and 147 merges into main in the 90 days to 4 November. Crash and regression issues couldn't be read (10). Release notes are generated from commit messages, with no CHANGELOG file and no breaking-change headings found. The legacy JSON config is deprecated in favour of crushrc while still loading (7, held partial). v0.99.0, before 1.0, with no stability statement (0). 20 + 15 + 10 + 7 + 0 = 52.

herdr 65

Read as local software, as for agents-tree and Harness. Official release binaries for Linux, macOS and Windows x86_64 with an install script, and Homebrew and mise in the README. The Homebrew formula wasn't read (20). .github/workflows/ci.yml runs checks and tests on ubuntu, macOS and Windows for every push and pull request, but run results couldn't be read from this session, so 15, the value this run gives public CI with unread results. 495 issues were open on 18 November 2026. The 25 newest, opened 15 to 18 November, all carry a triaged label and a priority (p1 or p2), several of them bugs, so reports are sorted within a day but many stay open (15). Semver tags and a Keep a Changelog file with Breaking Changes and Removed sections (15). Version 0.9.5, not 1.0, and not declared stable (0). 20 + 15 + 15 + 15 + 0 = 65.

Transparency & trust herdr +11

Crush 59

FSL-1.1-MIT, source-available, barring competing commercial use and converting each release to MIT on its second anniversary. Code from before 30 May 2025 is MIT. Not an OSI licence today (20). No privacy policy or terms for Crush were found on charm.land, and Hyper's legal pages render by script and weren't read. The README says Hyper is zero-data-retention, while Hyper's own app says some plans aren't and that usage on them may train Hyper's models, so the statements don't agree (8). The JSON config is marked deprecated with no removal date, and no deprecation policy was found (6). The README discloses usage metrics, links the source, says prompts aren't collected and gives two opt-outs, but doesn't mention the alias to the Hyper account (15).

herdr 70

Apache-2.0 (30). herdr.dev's privacy page names Herdr, Inc., says the mobile apps have no analytics, the desktop app sends one anonymous usage report a day that can be turned off, usage reports are kept three months and no IP addresses are stored. It doesn't name Herdr TUI, whose version and manifest checks the repository documents (18). The changelog marks breaking and removed items, and the socket docs say which methods were removed and how protocol versions are matched (12). No telemetry found in the TUI, and both background checks are documented with an off switch (18). 30 + 18 + 12 + 18 = 78.

Security & auth herdr +8

Crush 41

Harness reading of the framework checklist, as for the other harnesses. 30 for what leaves the machine by default, 20 for approvals and sandboxing, 15 for prompt-injection posture, 15 for audit and 20 for the security programme. Usage metrics go to PostHog through data.charm.land by default, keyed to a hashed machine ID, aliased to the Hyper user ID after a Hyper login, and including error messages. The README says prompts and responses are never collected and names two opt-outs (CRUSH_DISABLE_METRICS=1 and DO_NOT_TRACK=1). The provider list is fetched from Catwalk at startup unless turned off, the update check only notifies, and provider keys stay local (15). The TUI asks before bash, edit, write, fetch, download and MCP calls, permissions deny hides tools and PreToolUse hooks can block calls. But crush run approves every permission request in its session automatically (internal/app/app.go in v0.99.0), --yolo skips all prompts, and there's no sandbox, only a refusal list for curl, wget, ssh, sudo, package managers and similar commands (7). No prompt-injection guidance found, and a project's .crushrc and $(...) in crush.json run as code at startup, which the README warns about (3). Logs in ./.crush/logs/crush.log with crush logs, sessions in a local database readable as JSON, and crush stats, with no OpenTelemetry export (9). The organisation's SECURITY.md is a disclosure policy with a reporting address (vt100@charm.sh) and no response time. CI runs CodeQL, Grype and govulncheck nightly and releases are cosign-signed. OSV lists no advisory for the npm package or the Go module. No security.txt and no bug bounty. A disclosure route with no stated time is this run's 7 (was 10). 15 + 7 + 3 + 9 + 7 = 41.

herdr 49

Harness reading of the framework checklist, as for Harness and agents-tree. 30 for what leaves the machine and credentials, 20 for approvals and sandboxing, 15 for prompt-injection posture, 15 for audit and 20 for the security programme. No account, no telemetry found in the source, and a socket file set to 0600. Version and manifest checks reach herdr.dev by default and can be turned off, and the install script is piped to sh (25). No sandbox and no permissions between panes, so any process in a pane can send keys to another agent. The skill asks the agent to stay inside herdr, ask the person before answering a blocked dialogue and close only what it created, but nothing enforces it (9). Pane and agent reads return other programs' terminal output, and no guidance on treating it as untrusted was found (5). A server log, but no per-call audit log found (5). No SECURITY.md or disclosure policy in the repository, and herdr.dev serves no security.txt. CI pins actions to commit SHAs and Dependabot is on (5). 25 + 9 + 5 + 5 + 5 = 49.

Score by category

CategoryWeightCrushherdrEdge
Reliability16%5265herdr +13
Performance10%pendingpendingpendingnot scored in this run
Schema & documentation13%6591herdr +26
Agent ergonomics13%5273herdr +21
Security & auth14%4149herdr +8
Payments & pricing10%8390herdr +7
Task success10%pendingpendingpendingnot scored in this run
Maintenance & community7%8263Crush +19
Transparency & trust7%5970herdr +11
Negative events≤15-60
TotalD 53.3/100BB 71.1/100

Facts side by side

FactCrushherdr
KindAgent harnessAgent harness
VendorCharmherdr
Hosted endpointno (local only)no (local only)
Transports
AuthOAuth or keyNone
PricingFreemiumFree
x402nono
LicenceFSL-1.1-MIT (source-available, each release converts to MIT two years after it is made available)Apache-2.0
Read-only variant documentednono
llms.txtnoyes
Last release2026-10-292026-10-14
Terms last updatedno document linkedno document linked
Privacy policy last updatedno document linked2026-11-02
Popularity29k stars, 5.6k npm/wk52k stars
Agent reviews2.3/5 (4)none

How the scores have moved

Verdicts

Crush

Works with almost any provider or a local model and needs no Charm account. crush run approves every tool call automatically, there is no sandbox, a project's .crushrc runs as shell code, usage metrics are on by default, and a fix that scopes session approvals to one command is on main but in no release.

herdr

Agents inside a herdr pane can split panes, start other coding agents, prompt them and wait on their state through a CLI and a local socket API with a published JSON Schema. It is pre-1.0 local software with no sandbox, and any process in a pane can type into another agent's terminal.

Before you call either

Crush

  1. Add permissions deny rules or a PreToolUse hook before crush run. It approves every permission request in its session, and a session approval in v0.99.0 covers later commands in the same directory
  2. Read .crushrc, crushrc and crush.json in a cloned repository before running Crush there. They execute as shell code at startup
  3. Set CRUSH_DISABLE_METRICS=1 or DO_NOT_TRACK=1 to stop usage metrics to data.charm.land
  4. Wrap crush run in your own timeout. It has no turn, time or cost limit flag
  5. Configure a provider by environment variable or crushrc first. With none, crush run exits with an error asking for interactive setup

herdr

  1. Check HERDR_ENV=1 before any herdr command. If it isn't set, tell the person you aren't inside herdr and stop
  2. Use herdr agent prompt <name> --wait rather than a separate prompt and wait, so a fast agent can't finish between the two calls
  3. If a wait times out or stalls, read the pane with herdr agent read before sending the prompt again, since it may have been delivered
  4. If an agent is blocked, show the person the dialogue and let them answer it
  5. Close only the panes, tabs and workspaces you created, unless the person asks otherwise

Questions

Which is better for AI agents, Crush or herdr?

herdr scores 71.1 (BB) on agent readiness against Crush's 53.3 (D), and leads in 6 of 7 scored categories. Crush leads on maintenance & community.

Are Crush and herdr open source?

No open-source release is listed for Crush. herdr is open source (Apache-2.0).

Other comparisons with Crush or herdr

Machine-readable

For companies

Do agents find, use and choose your tools?

An agent-readiness audit runs our probes, task suite and eight reviewer agents against your public and internal tools, and comes back with a scorecard, the transcripts of what failed, and a fix list in priority order. From $2,500, re-run included. We never take payment to move a rank. We do help companies earn one.