Mirror CLI vs Sculptor

Mirror CLI 75

Framework reading. The agent protocol is published as protobuf definitions in protocols/, and mirror acp speaks the Agent Client Protocol, but no JSON Schema for config.json or the MCP definition files was found (15 of 25). llms.txt with a Markdown copy of every page (10). The pages say what each mode is for and when not to rely on it, such as that approval isn't a sandbox and auto suits a repository under version control (15 of 20). Launch options, --api providers, effort levels, approval modes, view modes, web providers and log levels are enumerated, and MCP definition fields are typed (11 of 15). Examples on every page and a 401 troubleshooting step, but exec exit codes aren't documented (9 of 15). Versions with a stated tag scheme (reflection-mirror-vX.Y.Z for the CLI, mirror-agent-vX.Y.Z for the agent) and a public CHANGELOG.md in the repository since 22 October 2026 (15).

Sculptor 45

Harness reading. A README, specs and agent docs in the repository; no API reference (45).

Mirror CLI 47

0.1.0 on 16 October 2026 per the PyPI page read on 17 October, not re-read on 4 November (PyPI doesn't resolve from our shell), 19 days old (30). The 90-day line needs three dated releases. 0.1.0 (16 October) and the mirror-agent-v0.1.8 tag on the same commit, f938033, are one release day, and 0.1.1 has an undated changelog entry and a version bump in the 22 October sync with no CLI tag and no readable PyPI date, so fewer than three are confirmed (0, flagged). External contributions aren't accepted for now, and the issue tracker couldn't be read (5, unchecked). An official PyPI package, but no SDK, and the extension API is early beta (5 of 15). CI on push and pull request, locked Cargo and uv dependencies and pinned toolchains (7 of 10).

Sculptor 75

Commits on 6 November 2026 and frequent tagged versions (30). More than three releases in 90 days (20). GitHub issues and pull requests weren't read (GitHub's pages refuse these sessions), so that line is scored absent; the README says Imbue can't take many outside contributions yet (0). Current official downloads (15). CI on pull requests (10). 30 + 20 + 0 + 15 + 10 = 75.

Mirror CLI 66

Apache-2.0, with NOTICE and third-party licences in the repository (30). The README and SECURITY.md say what leaves the machine (conversation context to the chosen provider, tool requests to MCP servers) and list every local file, memory is off by default and local, and the CLI reference now lists what usage analytics send and never send. Reflection's privacy policy is on reflection.ai, whose robots.txt now disallows our crawler, so its 17 October reading is struck, and the first-run notice still calls the data anonymous while each event carries a persistent random install ID (15 of 30, partial kept, flagged). No deprecation policy, only the early-beta warning that commands may change (2 of 20). Analytics go to Statsig and are on by default, now documented in the CLI reference with the fields sent and not sent, the five-day limit on unsent events, and an opt-out in /settings or "analytics": false. Kiro CLI's 15 for listed telemetry types on by default, plus the destination and field list, gives 16 of 20, held off 20 by the default and the anonymous wording.

Sculptor 57

MIT (30). Consent-based telemetry documented in the repository (18 of 30). The README warns of drastic changes during the research preview, with no deprecation policy (5). Opt-in telemetry (20). 30 + 18 + 5 + 20 = 73.

Mirror CLI 58

Framework reading, adapted to a harness driven by a pipeline. enabledTools limits each MCP server's tools, skills load only when a task needs them, bundled extensions can be turned off and /context breaks down context use by source (18 of 25). --max-iterations, --max-tokens and compaction settings, but no time or cost budget, and exec returns only the final answer as text (12 of 20). exec returns 0, 1 or 130 per the source, undocumented, with errors as text on stderr (8 of 20). Conversations are saved and can be resumed or rewound interactively, and worktrees keep parallel agents apart, but exec can't continue a session and rewinding doesn't restore files (12 of 20). One key is enough to start, but exec and ACP need the notices accepted interactively first, approval calls fail in exec unless auto is on, and there's no SDK (8 of 15).

Sculptor 50

Harness reading. Workspaces as isolated copies, review and merge back, and built-in skills (50).