ONES vs OpenProject

ONES 40

Scored on the MCP server and the Open API together. 67 MCP tools load by default (5), and a client granted fewer scope groups is limited to fewer tools (5 back). Lists take limit and cursor with project and issue type filters, and query_issues_by_onesql runs a filtered query (15 of 20). Error status codes are documented per endpoint with response schemas, but no error code catalogue was found (8 of 20). No idempotency keys or MCP annotations found (0). One official SDK, @ones-open/node-sdk, aimed at ONES Apps, and the MCP setup is one mcp-remote line (7 of 15). 10 + 15 + 8 + 0 + 7 = 40.

OpenProject 70

Graded on the REST API. Collections take pageSize and offset, and eight collection endpoints, work packages among them, take select to trim fields. HAL responses embed related resources in full by default (14 of 25). Filters with operators, sortBy, grouping and saved queries (20). Errors carry an errorIdentifier URN and a message, and validation failures arrive as MultipleErrors with one entry per property (18 of 20). No idempotency keys. lockVersion stops lost updates, form endpoints validate a change without saving it, and each tool of the paid MCP server sets read-only, destructive and idempotent hints (12 of 20). No official SDK was found. The docs list community clients for JavaScript and Go that the vendor says it does not vet. Creating a work package needs a subject and links to a project and type (6 of 15).

ONES 25

Graded as a hosted service on ONES.com Cloud's Open API and MCP server. No status page is linked from ones.com, the trust centre or the docs, and status.ones.com did not resolve (0). With no readable history the incident line scores 5. No rate limit with numbers was found in the developer docs index or the terms, which only reserve the right to restrict excessive traffic (0). No 429, backoff or idempotency guidance found (0). The pricing page states 99.9% uptime on Business and 99.95% on Enterprise (10). The MCP server has been in the release notes since 6.42.0 on 26 August 2025 and carries no beta label (10). 0 + 5 + 0 + 0 + 10 + 10 = 25.

OpenProject 52

Graded on the APIv3 of OpenProject Enterprise cloud, with the hosted lines. The same API ships in the free Community edition. Status page at status.openproject.com, run on UptimeRobot, with a 90-day uptime view and an update history (20). On 4 November the page still drew its figures and history by script from /api/, which its robots.txt disallows, so the incident record from 6 August could not be read (5, unread and not a finding against the vendor). No request limit for the API is published for the cloud. The only documented rule is an optional one for self-hosted installs, six requests per three seconds on form endpoints, off by default (3 of 15, partly met). No 429 or Retry-After guidance and no idempotency keys were found. Updates must send lockVersion, and a stale value is refused with 409 UpdateConflict (4 of 15, partly met). The service description, last updated 28 August 2026 and re-read on 4 November, commits to 99.9 per cent availability a year with SLA credits (10). APIv3 is described as the stable API (10). 20 + 5 + 3 + 4 + 10 + 10 = 52.

ONES 62

Closed service under terms naming The Beautiful ONES Technology PTE. LTD. and Singapore law (15 of 30). The privacy policy of 7 January 2026 deletes business data 30 days after a service ends with no login for 365 days, and honours deletion requests within 30 days, but no DPA or subprocessor list is public (12 of 30). Endpoint version histories record changes, with no deprecation policy (5 of 20). The privacy policy names AWS, Oracle cloud and OpenAI and says data is transferred mostly to the US, China and Singapore, with no subprocessor list or regions (6 of 20). 15 + 12 + 5 + 6 = 38.

OpenProject 87

The source is public under GPL-3.0, Enterprise add-ons included, with those add-ons unlocked by a paid token. The cloud runs under the Terms of Service of 6 August 2026 (28 of 30). The privacy policy of 30 July 2026 covers the cloud and names OpenProject GmbH as processor. An instance is deleted six months after the contract ends, web logs within 90 days, and the terms give 21 days' notice to export data. The data processing agreement follows the EU standard clauses and was last updated on 28 March 2024 (25 of 30). No deprecation policy with dates was found. The docs say the vendor strives to keep APIv3 backward compatible in stable releases, and 14 operations are marked deprecated with no removal date (7 of 20). The sub-processor list of 18 May 2026 names four companies for the openproject.com shard (AWS among them) and three for the EU shard (Scaleway among them), with addresses and transfer safeguards (19 of 20). Self-hosted installs call OpenProject's Release API for the update badge by default, which the privacy policy (version 30 July 2026) describes with its fields and an opt-out.

ONES 55

No downloadable OpenAPI file was found. The reference is rendered pages, and the MCP docs list tool names and one-line descriptions without input schemas (0). llms.txt with sized indexes and a Markdown copy of every page (10). Endpoint and tool descriptions state what each does in one line, with version history per endpoint but little on when not to use one (10 of 20). Parameters are typed with defaults, limits (limit at most 100) and required marks (10 of 15). Each endpoint lists 200, 401, 403, 404 and 500 responses with schemas and examples (10 of 15). API version 2.0, a History table per endpoint and dated release notes (15). 0 + 10 + 10 + 10 + 10 + 15 = 55.

OpenProject 76

A public OpenAPI 3.1 document with 234 paths and 320 operations, downloadable from the docs site and served by every instance at /api/v3/spec.json and /api/v3/spec.yml (25). No llms.txt (the path returns 404). The docs are Markdown files in the public repository, not served to agents from the docs site (2 of 10). The reference explains HAL links, collections, filters, forms and each resource's permissions at length, with little on when not to use an endpoint (14 of 20). 204 component schemas and 95 enumerations, but write bodies are HAL objects with _links, filters travel as a JSON string in the query, and custom fields appear as customFieldN. Form endpoints return the allowed values for a given resource (10 of 15). The spec carries about 1,200 examples and lists 400, 403, 404, 406, 415 and 422 responses per operation, with stable error identifiers (14 of 15). The version sits in the path and release notes are dated and list API changes. No changelog for the API alone was found (11 of 15).

ONES 68

Latest dated release notes are 7.33.0 on 30 September 2026, 37 days before this check. The registry entry moved to 1.0.3 on 8 October with no release note behind it, so it doesn't set recency (20). Nine dated releases since 8 August, several adding Open API endpoints or MCP capabilities (7.23.0, 7.26.0, 7.27.0, 7.29.0) (20). Closed service with a public changelog and support by email, with no public issue tracker (8 of 15). Verified com.ones/ones namespace in the official MCP registry (15). One official SDK for apps, with package health not checked (5 of 10). 20 + 20 + 8 + 15 + 5 = 68.

OpenProject 75

Version 18.0.0 was released on 2 November 2026, after 17.9.2 (15 October), 17.9.3 (22 October), 17.9.4 (26 October), 17.9.5 and 17.9.6 (30 October) (30). Twelve releases in the 90 days from 6 August, 17.7.1 through 18.0.0 (20). OpenProject tracks bugs on community.openproject.org, which we did not sample, so responsiveness is scored on the release record and the advisory handling alone, with fixes published alongside each advisory (15 of 25). No official SDK and no MCP registry entry were found (0 of 15). The repository runs test, CodeQL, Brakeman, Semgrep, dependency review and npm audit workflows, the test workflow running unit and browser test suites and validating the API spec on push and pull request, and the default branch had commits on 4 November 2026 (10). 30 + 20 + 15 + 0 + 10 = 75.

ONES 65

OAuth for MCP clients with per-scope consent, Personal API keys created with chosen scopes and shown once, organisation credentials, token introspection and revocation, all sent as Bearer headers (30). Scope groups allow a read-only grant, and the docs advise revoking unused clients, but writes run without a confirmation step and the consent page preselects every group (12 of 20). Tools return issue, comment and wiki text written by other users plus search_external_web results, and no prompt-injection guidance was found (0). The authorised client list shows each client's grant time and last active time, and on-premises installs document an audit log (8 of 15). security.txt valid until June 2027, and the trust centre lists SOC 2 Type II, ISO 27001 and ISO 27018 without report access or a bug bounty (15 of 20). 30 + 12 + 0 + 8 + 15 = 65.

OpenProject 59

OAuth 2.0 with the authorisation code grant, PKCE and client credentials, with one scope per API (api_v3, mcp, scim_v2, bcf_v2_1) and none finer. Personal API tokens are named, can be several and can be deleted, and carry their user's full permissions. No expiry or per-token scope was found. Tokens travel in the Authorization header only (22 of 30). Reach is limited by project roles and permissions, so a dedicated user with a read-only role is the least-privilege route, and administrators can switch off single MCP tools. No confirmation step for deletes (12 of 20). Work package text and comments are untrusted content, and no prompt-injection guidance was found in the API or MCP docs (2 of 15). Every change to a work package is journalled with its author, and application logs record sign-ins and credential changes. No per-token API log for a cloud customer was found (8 of 15). A signed security.txt valid to 31 December 2026, a disclosure policy with a 21-day target for critical fixes, advisories and CVEs published on GitHub, signed container images with SBOMs, and a YesWeHack bounty paid for by the European Commission. No SOC 2 or ISO 27001 certificate for the vendor was found (15 of 20).