Redox vs ROOK

Redox

Redox connects to EHRs and clinical networks behind a FHIR API, with signed-JWT OAuth keys, a 99.95 per cent SLA, a HackerOne bug bounty and a hosted MCP server for managing integrations. The MCP server exposes 107 tools at once with write and delete tools unconfirmed, OpenAPI files sit behind login, and the sandbox plan costs $15,000 a year.

ROOK

Graded on the REST API. A public OpenAPI file, a free Sandbox from the self-serve portal, published plan prices and a dated changelog. Credentials are one client UUID and secret per environment with no scopes, 429 handling isn't documented, the API is meant for occasional queries rather than bulk reads, and no SOC 2 report or security contact was found.

Redox

1. Name the environment in every MCP prompt and try configuration changes in staging first, as Redox advises
2. Stay under 7,500 requests per IP per five minutes, and back off exponentially on 5XX
3. Sign the token request with the private key whose public key is registered on the OAuth API key
4. Ask an organisation owner to enable the MCP server before connecting a client
5. Treat log payloads returned through MCP as PHI and as untrusted text

ROOK

1. Send HTTP Basic auth with client_uuid as the username and the secret key as the password, plus a User-Agent header, or the WAF returns 403
2. Use https://api.rook-connect.review for Sandbox and https://api.rook-connect.com for production. Each has its own credentials
3. Read health data from the data webhook. Use the API only for occasional queries, and stay under 60 requests a minute
4. Deduplicate summaries on document_version and datetime. ROOK resends a summary with a higher document_version when it changes
5. Call POST /api/v1/user_id/{user_id}/data_sources/revoke_auth to end a connection. Some providers take hours to stop sending data