Niches · Secrets & credential vaults
Have a person approve a sensitive read at run time
No company's docs show a full fit yet. The listings below do the job with a limit, or not at all.
What counts as done
The read pauses, the person gets a prompt on a phone or chat naming the agent and the secret, and an approval releases the value or the brokered call while a denial or no answer in the set time returns a typed refusal.
Measured, for our own tests: the approval releases it within 60 seconds. No docs we read state these figures, so they don't count against a listing here.
How agents ask for it: ask me before the agent uses the production key
, approve this secret from my phone
Does the job, with a limit 5
It does the job, but something in the docs or a user's account will get in an agent's way. The limit is named in each row.
| Listing | Why |
|---|---|
| 1Password service accounts, SDKs and Environments MCP BB AgileBits Inc. (doing business as 1Password) | The Environments MCP and OpenShell connections show an authorisation prompt in the desktop app, on the same machine. Service accounts have no approval step, and acc-04 wants a phone approval that does not exist. source |
| Akeyless (SecretlessAI and MCP server) BB Akeyless Security Ltd. | Request Access lets an identity ask for temporary read on an item, approved in the Event Center or ServiceNow, with a 60-minute default grant. It is a separate request, not a paused read with a deny-on-timeout. source |
| HashiCorp Vault + Vault MCP Server C HashiCorp, Inc. (an IBM company) | Control groups return a wrapping token instead of the data until named authorisers approve, and the wrapping TTL bounds the wait. Enterprise only, and approval goes through the Vault API or UI, not a phone or chat prompt. source |
| Keeper Secrets Manager B Keeper Security, Inc. | The MCP server asks for confirmation in the client before returning an unmasked value, unless --auto-approve is set. That is the chat client's session, with no timeout or phone prompt; SDK and ksm reads have no approval. source |
| Pulumi ESC BB Pulumi Corporation | Open approvals (Pro and Enterprise) make a user submit an open request with a reason and duration that reviewers approve before access. It is a request workflow ahead of the read, with no stated timeout or phone prompt. source |
Doesn't do this job 7
Listings in the category that do something else, with the reason.
| Listing | Why |
|---|---|
| AWS Secrets Manager A Amazon Web Services, Inc. (Amazon Web Services EMEA SARL and other regional entities by account location) | Secrets Manager has no step that pauses a read for a person's approval; access is decided by IAM policy alone. source |
| Azure Key Vault BB Microsoft Corporation | No approval step pauses a secret read; access is granted by role assignment alone. source |
| Bitwarden Secrets Manager C Bitwarden Inc. (terms name 8bit Solutions LLC, wholly owned by Bitwarden Inc.) | No approval step for a machine account's read is documented. source |
| Doppler BB Doppler Technologies, Inc. | Change requests gate edits to secrets, not reads; no approval for a read is documented. source |
| Google Cloud Secret Manager BB Google LLC (Google Cloud EMEA Limited and other regional entities by billing address) | No approval step pauses an AccessSecretVersion call; access is IAM only. source |
| Infisical AA Infisical, Inc. | Agent Vault hooks answer allow or deny within 3 seconds, too short for a person, and temporary access is granted ahead of time, not by pausing a read. source |
| Phase B Phi Security Inc. | No approval step for reading a secret is documented. source |
What stops agents finishing
- service accounts have no approval step, only desktop-app biometric unlock
- approval tied to a desktop session on the same machine
Around it
Before: secrets.scoped-read. After: human-in-the-loop.approve-action.
Where this comes from
Weight 5 of 100 in Secrets & credential vaults: 2 of 27 accounts (1Password remote approval wish, runtime supervision); no listing has it for machine reads, so it is a gap rather than a job done today
The same as data: /api/v1/use-cases/secrets.approve-read.json, or the MCP tool get_use_case with id secrets.approve-read. Other jobs in this category: /api/v1/niches?category=secrets.
For companies
Do agents find, use and choose your tools?
An agent-readiness audit runs our probes, task suite and eight reviewer agents against your public and internal tools, and comes back with a scorecard, the transcripts of what failed, and a fix list in priority order. From $2,500, re-run included. We never take payment to move a rank. We do help companies earn one.