Write and sing a complete song from a prompt or lyrics
No company's docs show a full fit yet. The listings below do the job with a limit, or not at all.
What counts as done
A song of at least 90 seconds sung from the supplied lyrics and sections in the requested language, returned as a playable file, or a refusal that names its reason, from one job.
Measured, for our own tests: the sung lyrics match the supplied text and sections, and the job finishes within 5 minutes. No docs we read state these figures, so they don't count against a listing here.
How agents ask for it: make a song about this
, turn these lyrics into a song
, a personalised birthday song
, a 2-minute song about my coding session
Does the job, with a limit 7
It does the job, but something in the docs or a user's account will get in an agent's way. The limit is named in each row.
| Listing | Why |
|---|---|
| ElevenLabs Music API BB Eleven Labs Inc. | Sections carry lyric lines and durations up to 600,000 ms, and a copyright refusal returns bad_prompt with a prompt suggestion. The call is synchronous with no job id or idempotency key, and acc-07 found non-English vocals patchy. source |
| fal music models BB Features & Labels, Inc. | Mureka 9.5 sings up to 5,000 characters of lyrics with a target duration and returns timed lyric sections; the queue returns an id first, and errors are typed, with optional content-policy categories. Language fidelity and the 5-minute bar aren't stated, and no idempotency key exists. source |
| Google Lyria D Google LLC | Lyria 3.5 sings supplied lyrics with section tags in the prompt's language and returns lyrics with the audio. Refusals arrive without a category (acc-15), a timeout can bill a song with no id (acc-28), one SDK path fails (acc-19), and charges show hours later (acc-10). source |
| Loudly Music API F Loudly GmbH | POST /api/ai/manta/songs takes lyrics, gender and instrumental=false, but needs Loudly to switch on manta_access (403 otherwise), has no length field, and states no refusal or language behaviour. source |
| MusicGPT API D MusicGPT Ltd | Lyrics, model choice and lyric timestamps go in; a task id and per-request is_flagged with a reason string come back. No maximum length or language support is stated, and no idempotency key exists, so a blind retry may bill again. source |
| Soundverse API E Soundverse Inc. | generate_song takes up to 3,000 characters of lyrics with gender or a saved voice, returns a job id at once and takes an Idempotency-Key. Song length isn't a parameter or published, and content refusals have no named error type, only a failed status with error_message. source |
| Suno MCP F Suno, Inc. (United States, terms governed by Massachusetts law) | The server turns ideas and lyrics into songs saved to the library, but tool schemas, refusal behaviour and job handling are unpublished, and acc-23 had to stop for a human when only library ids came back. source |
Doesn't do this job 5
Listings in the category that do something else, with the reason.
| Listing | Why |
|---|---|
| Beatoven.ai API F Beatoven Private Limited (with subsidiary Beatoven Inc.) | The spec has one prompt field and no lyrics or vocal option; output is an instrumental with bass, chords, melody and percussion stems. source |
| Mubert API F Mubert Inc. | Generation takes prompts, images or playlists with no lyrics input; acc-34 found its Mubert adapter can't sing. source |
| MusicGen on Replicate B Replicate, LLC | The inputs are a text prompt and an optional melody clip; there's no lyrics input or vocal output. source |
| SOUNDRAW API F SOUNDRAW Inc. | Instrumental background music only; the compose parameters have no lyrics or vocals. source |
| Stable Audio API F Stability AI Ltd (UK, EU, Switzerland) and Stability AI US Services Corporation (elsewhere) | No lyrics or vocal parameter on any audio route; acc-34 found its Stable Audio adapter can't sing. source |
What stops agents finishing
- HTTP 200 with PROHIBITED_CONTENT and no category, so the agent can't tell what to change (acc-15)
- a synchronous call that bills a song it can't return after a timeout (acc-28)
- no Suno API outside the MCP server, and the unofficial web route breaks on captchas and encrypted downloads (acc-13, acc-20, acc-21)
- the same model fails through one SDK path and works through another (acc-19)
- charges show hours after the call, so a retry loop overspends unseen (acc-10)
Around it
Before: inference.chat-completion. After: file-storage.upload-file, social-media.publish-post.
Where this comes from
Weight 27 of 100 in Music generation: 12 of 43 links, the largest group: Lyria, ElevenLabs and Suno song attempts on HN, the Google AI forum and GitHub, of which 7 are failure reports (refusals, lost billed jobs, SDK errors, the unofficial Suno route breaking)
The same as data: /api/v1/use-cases/music-generation.full-song-vocals.json, or the MCP tool get_use_case with id music-generation.full-song-vocals. Other jobs in this category: /api/v1/niches?category=music-generation.
For companies
Do agents find, use and choose your tools?
An agent-readiness audit runs our probes, task suite and eight reviewer agents against your public and internal tools, and comes back with a scorecard, the transcripts of what failed, and a fix list in priority order. From $2,500, re-run included. We never take payment to move a rank. We do help companies earn one.