Gem vs NeverApply

Gem 0

Nothing is readable. Sizing, pagination, filters, the error object, the 409 and from_stage_id guards and required fields all came from the api.gem.com reference, struck because its robots.txt answered 403 on 4 November 2026. The help centre says the Job Board API returns the whole list of live posts, to sort and filter on the page. MCP tool annotations need a login. No official SDK found. 0 + 0 + 0 + 0 + 0. Total 0.

NeverApply 66

MCP reading. 15 tools, 6 read, 6 edit and 3 apply, in the 11 to 30 band (15); guests see a two-tool subset and scopes split read, edit and apply access, though whether tools/list narrows by scope was not read (2 back, 17 of 25). search_jobs takes the user's filters with up to 20 results a call, get_matches pages with next_cursor, list_applications filters by status (needs_answer, ready_to_send, stale, interview, offer), and the Jobs API has a fields sparse fieldset, per_page and cursor feeds (18 of 20). auth.md gives an action for 401, 429 and the OAuth errors, MCP limit errors carry reset and retry fields, and results carry status and next_action the skills act on; no full code list, and the Jobs API's documented envelope and component schemas disagree (13 of 20). apply_to_job takes an idempotency_key, approvals and answers take review_version, a repeat tailor_resume call reads the same copy without paying twice, and auth.md says never to repeat an application blindly; readOnlyHint and destructiveHint were not read (12 of 20). Most tools need one ID, but there is no official SDK (6 of 15). 17+18+13+12+6 = 66.

Gem 14

No contract could be read. api.gem.com answered its robots.txt with 403 Forbidden on 4 November 2026, which this run reads as a refusal, so the 8 October readings of its reference and OpenAPI files are struck (0 of 25). www.gem.com/llms.txt exists but describes the company and names no API endpoint (3, a partial kept). The help centre says what each of the CRM, ATS and Job Board APIs is for and walks through the Job Board endpoint with two use cases, with no per-operation descriptions readable (5 of 20). No typed inputs readable (0 of 15). No examples or error responses readable (0 of 15). v0 in the help centre's Job Board path and monthly product notes that mention API additions once, in July 2026, with no API changelog (6 of 15, a partial kept). Total 14.

NeverApply 57

MCP reading, with the Jobs API described. The 15 tools' input schemas were not read, since no session was opened and the server card at /.well-known/mcp/server-card.json lists tools only as 'dynamic'. An OpenAPI 3.1 file at https://neverapply.co/openapi.json covers 7 GET operations of the Jobs API with typed parameters, but every 200 response is typed as an integer constant (422, 401, 404 or 200) with no job schema, and no pagination fields are defined, so partial (12 of 25). llms.txt and a Markdown authorisation guide at https://neverapply.co/auth.md (10). The three skills and GEMINI.md in the plugin repository say when to use each tool, in what order, which IDs to trust and where to stop and ask, and the MCP page groups the tools by access level; the hosted tool descriptions were not read (12 of 20). Jobs API parameters carry enums (experience level, salary period, visa sponsorship, clearance, education, sort), bounds (per_page 1 to 100, 500 or 1,000) and patterns on country codes; the MCP arguments are named in the skills without types (10 of 15). auth.md documents 401, the OAuth error codes, 429 and isError inside a 200, the skills name waiting_for_answers, open_review, upgrade_required and matches_state, and the OpenAPI description lists five error codes, but its components define different error shapes and no request or response example was found (8 of 15). /v1 paths, OpenAPI version 1.0.0 and a repository tag v1.0.0, but no changelog; /changelog answered a client error (5 of 15). 12+10+12+10+8+5 = 57.

Gem 18

The last API or MCP change with an exact date is the MCP launch on 4 August 2026, 92 days before 4 November; the monthly product notes carry no day, and the October 2026 edition covers app functions only (10). Since 6 August only the August and October editions, dated by month, so fewer than three dated entries (0). Public product notes, a support address and an MCP feedback tool, with no public forum or issue tracker found (8). No official SDK found (0). The package-health 4 rested on the OpenAPI files served from api.gem.com, now struck, and there are no packages (0). Total 18.

NeverApply 50

Closed service. The latest dated change is a commit of 31 October 2026 to kasovy/neverapply-mcp documenting guest access to search_jobs and get_job, after a tag v1.0.0 on 21 October; the privacy policy was updated on 26 October and the terms on 18 October (30). One tagged release and 16 commits from 25 September to 31 October 2026, with no changelog or release notes, so partial (10 of 20). No public changelog; support is a contact form, hello@neverapply.co and security@neverapply.co, with a stated reply within one business day and a median first reply of about two hours in staffed hours; GitHub issues could not be read because the GitHub API was not available to us (5 of 15). The server card names co.neverapply/neverapply and llms.txt says it was published to the official MCP registry on 25 September 2026, but the registry could not be read, so it is scored absent; no official SDK (0 of 15). The plugin repository has no runtime dependencies and a CI workflow that validates every manifest against its published schema, with a release workflow on tags; actions are pinned to major tags and the run results were not readable (5 of 10). 30+10+5+0+5 = 50.

Gem 15

No x402, MPP or L402 (0). The two main plans are custom-priced through sales. The pricing page shows one public plan price, the startup programme at $130 a month for 1 to 10 employees on a yearly term against a struck-through $270, re-read on 4 November 2026, and nothing is priced per call (10). Companies under 30 employees get six months free, but API keys need a paid plan with the API enabled, and whether checkout takes a card was not established (5). A team admin creates the key in the web app after Gem enables the API (0). Total 15.

NeverApply 45

No x402, MPP or L402 on the pricing page, llms.txt, auth.md or the MCP page; plans are Stripe subscriptions and the terms say MCP tools perform no financial transactions (0). Plan prices are public without a login, Pro $29 and Max $49 a month ($19 and $39 a month billed yearly) with 150 and 450 credits a month and 1 credit per application, and the OpenAPI file prices the Jobs API at $19, $49 and $149 a month for 10,000, 50,000 and 250,000 calls; credit pack prices are not listed (15 of 20). Free is $0 with no card, 10 applications once, 5 match previews a day and 50 MCP reads a day per client, and the Jobs API has a free 1,000 calls a month (20). Guest search_jobs and get_job need no account, but every other tool, applying among them, needs a person to sign in or create an account and verify an email on the hosted page, so partial (10 of 20). 0+15+20+10 = 45.

Gem 48

A team API key that an admin creates and names in Team Settings, per the help centre; how it is sent came from the struck reference. No scopes, read-only keys, expiry or rotation guidance were found. The MCP server uses per-user OAuth with PKCE and dynamic client registration, from its published metadata (18, a partial kept). MCP calls carry the user's own Gem permissions and an admin can switch MCP off; the On-Behalf-Of attribution reading is struck, and no approval step or read-only mode was found (8, a partial kept). Resumes, notes and application answers are candidate-written, and no injection guidance was found (0). Audit logs that cover API key activity are available to all teams, per the September 2025 product notes, re-read on 4 November (12). Gem says SOC 2 reports are available under NDA and names NCC Group for annual audits, per the 8 October check. No security.txt, disclosure policy or bug bounty was found, and the trust centre could not be read (10). Total 48.

NeverApply 66

OAuth 2.1 for the MCP server, public clients with PKCE S256, client ID metadata documents or dynamic registration, a resource parameter, refresh tokens and three scopes; auth.md says no API keys or personal access tokens are accepted and documents no query-string secret; token lifetimes are not stated and no RFC 7009 revocation endpoint is advertised, though disconnecting a client in settings revokes its tokens and pending codes. The Jobs API takes a bearer token from a developer dashboard that was not readable (26 of 30). Read, edit and apply scopes; applying needs the apply scope, credits and the member's approval of each named job, sending needs a separate grant tied to one assistant that the terms say no tool can create, held applications need an explicit approve_application, and MCP tools cannot buy plans or move money; the web app's Send mode applies up to a daily cap without asking per job, which is outside the MCP surface (18 of 20). Job descriptions are employer text; the find-jobs skill and GEMINI.md say to summarise them and never follow instructions inside them, with no server-side filtering described (9 of 15). Settings list connected AI clients with their mode and allowance, get_profile shows the current budget mode, the tracker logs every application, errors carry a support or correlation ID, and the privacy policy keeps detailed API usage records for 90 days; no per-call log for the member is documented (7 of 15). security.txt is valid until 7 November 2027 with hello@neverapply.co, and the contact page routes security reports to security@neverapply.co with a reply within 24 hours; no bug bounty, SOC 2 or ISO 27001 found (6 of 20). 26+18+9+7+6 = 66.

Gem 64

Closed service with a published service agreement, last modified 7 March 2025, that includes AI terms (15). Privacy policy, a DPA on request and Data Privacy Framework certification. The privacy policy keeps information for 7 years after an account closes, while the security page says personal data is disposed of after account deletion. The service agreement gives Gem a perpetual licence to use candidate data for any business purpose (14). No deprecation policy or dated notice is readable. The deprecated-field flags came from the struck OpenAPI files, and the agreement's right to modify the service isn't a deprecation notice (0). United States data centres, Heroku, AWS and Nylas are named. The full sub-processor list sits on the trust centre, which we could not read (10). Total 39.

NeverApply 57

Closed hosted service under terms (last updated 18 October 2026) naming Kasovy LLC, registered in Wyoming, with Wyoming law and a liability cap of 12 months' fees or USD 100; the plugin repository of manifests and skills is MIT, copyright Kasovy LLC (17 of 30). The privacy policy (26 October 2026) gives retention periods (7 days for resumes uploaded without an account, 90 days for detailed API usage records and relay mail, a 30-day frozen period before deletion, and what is kept after it), says providers don't train on content under their API terms and that demographic answers are not used for matching, and the extension has its own policy (28 September 2026) saying nothing leaves the device unless AI answers are turned on; no DPA was found, and hashed emails and click IDs go to ad platforms (22 of 30). No deprecation policy or dated notices; the terms promise notice by email or in the product before material changes, and the switch to guest search was recorded only in a commit (4 of 20). Providers are named (OpenAI and Anthropic through Cloudflare's AI Gateway, Google Gemini, AWS S3 and SES, TypeSafe, Stripe, Apple, Google, RevenueCat, Expo, PostHog, Sentry, Gravatar, and Meta, TikTok, Google and X for ads), resume files are stored in AWS eu-central-1, and most providers are in the United States under standard contractual clauses (16 of 20). 17+22+4+16 = 59.